Skip to main content

Answer to Community Patent Consultation

Below is the email I sent in response to Community Patent Consultation organized by the FFII.
Dear All Concerned,

As a small businessman who started out as an entrepreneur out of university I currently employ 5 people. We serve reputable customers in Germany, providing them customized WLAN/802.11/Wireless network solutions.

We started our business with EUR 25,000 of capital from personal savings and family contributions. We never received any funding from an external investor and never a loan from a bank.

We did about 2 million EUR of revenue over the past 4 years of activity. And as a business owner I have never been as motivated about the future as I am today!


Starting out from zero, we were able to rely on the abundance of useful free software contributed by thousands of programmers worldwide. We stood on their giant shoulders and shaped their creations to suit the needs of our target customer group. When possible we gave back to free software groups and individuals in form of knowledge value-addition or at times just money.

We fear patent-regulation in Europe, because
  • We will not be able to innovate freely, living under the mighty cannons of resources of large corporates that could, at will, send a lawyer knocking our door - to us that would be equivalent to hell breaking loose.

    We may not have infringed any patent, and be on the moral and ethical right, but if we cannot hire a qualified lawyer who can defend our case, we won't be given the legal right. Depending on the severity imposed, we may have to pay a sum of money, or cancel certain projects, or even let some/all of our people home and scrape for last resources so we can pay legal bills. And honestly, I prefer to hire another engineer than a lawyer.

    We indeed write 10's of thousands of code every year. We couldn't do it well if we had to do it under constant fear of a major corporate suing us.

  • Secondly I believe the software industry has progressed so rapidly because of the open nature of this industry. All solid technologies like UNIX, JAVA, the WWW, Ethernet and scores of others are open-technologies/standards.

    The benefactors of such openness have been

    1) small businesses like us who could add value at a low entry-cost

    2) consumers, who know they are in safe hands given the fact that there are no secrets; and that they will get a better price given that no single party controls/restricts access to this technology. Again, I point to the above few examples.

  • Thirdly, large enterprises like Microsoft would love to control small businesses like us by forcing us to build solutions based on their proprietary technology. This way MS benefits economically, but also gains massively by having control on thousands of small businesses like us, and through us our customers.

    In this aspect, Open-software has been a savior, for us and for our customers.

We request you SAY NO TO SOFTWARE PATENTS. As a small business, we promise you that we can innovate better and add more value for our customers without them.

Best regards
Ashant Chalasani


Popular posts from this blog

Paypal's Ridiculous Business Practices

In Q3-2005 we discovered the power of online sales and started to market Wapsol's products extensively online. Just as importantly we decided to get into the trading business for WLAN accessories (antennae, cable, connectors etc) which entails buying from manufacturers and selling on online-retail. Needless to say ebay's 26 worldwide markets were lucrative points of sales.

We used Paypal for collecting most of payments from customers outside Germany. The numbers ticked up fast and we were hecticly building up infrastructure for shipping, online-support, product-portfolio and payment-systems.

One morning as I woke up in Germany I found that Paypal decided to lock up our account without any specific reason. There were no disputes or complaints from buyers or anything that suggested provocation. They just locked it. In it a few thousands of dollars of cash-flow and the account was listed as a favored payment option for some 100 pending auctions - now customers couldn't pay for …

The Dream of the Information Age

If this beauty of a device meets it's mission of being owned by every kid on the planet, we are looking to a new dimension of the Information Age.
For full profile of the device, visit BBC's technology page.

SnagIT Problem Solved! (Hangs for minutes)

Here's the solution to the SnagIT sluggishness (hangs for several minutes)
I would try first turning off the magnifier window under tools > program preferences > program options. Uncheck the box to show magnifier windows. Click apply > ok and then try the capture again.Check your security software and make sure that Snagit is set as a safe application. A security program that consistently scans the process will cause a very slow response like you are seeing.Please also check your printers per this article:Answer Title: Slow SnagIt startupAnswer Link:, please review the steps here and try these as well:Answer Title: SnagIt crashes or hangs when launchedAnswer Link: me know what happens.